Part I: Coming up with an idea
3. Who has this problem?
A problem starts with a person. Find someone you can talk to about it.
If you can't name or find someone who has the problem, assume it doesn't exist. You're not ready to build a product for them yet.
That might sound strict, but it gives you a useful next step. A real person can tell you what they're trying to do, show you where they get stuck, and explain what they've already tried. You can learn something from them that changes your idea.
“Small business owners” can't do that. Neither can an imaginary customer you've described in a document. Find an actual person you could contact.
Put a person in the sentence
In Chapter 1, you wrote “I want to help [person] with [problem].” In the same notes, make that more specific. Name someone you could talk to, what they're trying to do, and what you think is getting in their way:
Person X can't do Y because Z.
X is the person. Use their name in your own notes. Add the context that matters to the problem, such as the work they're doing or the situation they're in.
Y is what they're trying to get done. Describe an outcome they care about. “Finish a project” gives you more to work with than “use a better tool.”
Z is what's getting in their way. This is your current explanation, and it's often the part you know least about. Mark it as a guess if you haven't heard it from the person or seen it yourself.
Sometimes they can do Y, but it takes more effort than they can comfortably give it. Say that. The sentence is there to help you be precise; you don't need to force every problem into “can't.”
Make the problem specific enough to discuss
“Getting client feedback is hard” leaves a lot open. Whose feedback? What's hard about it? What is the person waiting to do?
For the hypothetical designer we've been following, a more useful version would be:
[Name] can't finish a design project because the client hasn't given a clear decision on the latest draft.
Replace [Name] with a real person when you write your own version. Our example is fictional; your next conversation needs someone who actually has the problem.
Notice how much this sentence leaves open. Perhaps the client hasn't looked at the draft. Perhaps several people have given conflicting feedback. Or perhaps the designer and client disagree about what counts as finished. We have a person and an outcome to ask about, but we still need to check the explanation.
You could also discover that the wait doesn't bother the designer. They have other work to do and the deadline is comfortable. Describing a difficulty in a sentence doesn't establish that someone wants it solved.
What if that person is you?
You count as a starting point. You can describe the last time it happened and what you did about it. That gives you something concrete to investigate.
If you're making a tool just for yourself, helping yourself may be enough. If you want other users, find someone else with the problem too. Your own experience can't tell you how it fits into another person's life, or whether they'd change what they do today.
What if you don't know anyone to ask?
Start with the type of person you have in mind, then look for someone you can contact. Ask people you know for an introduction, or look in a community where those people already spend time.
For our designer example, you could ask:
Do you know a freelance designer who works directly with clients? I'm trying to understand how they get feedback on their work. I'd like to talk to someone about how it went on a recent project.
You don't need to claim they have the problem before you've spoken to them. Find someone in the relevant situation, then ask what actually happens. They may tell you it works well for them. That's useful to learn too.
Take the problem you've chosen and write your sentence. If you have several possibilities, try a sentence for each. Set aside any you can't connect to a real person.
Beside the sentence, note what you already know about that person's experience and what you still need to ask. Having a name gives you someone to learn from; the conversation will help you check whether you've understood their problem.
Choose one problem and person to carry into the next chapter, where we'll question the way you've described it.