Skip to content

Part I: Coming up with an idea

7. From problem to idea

Choose a small way to help someone with a problem you understand.

Go back to the sentence we started with:

I want to help [person] with [problem].

You should now be able to fill it in with more confidence. You have someone to talk to, some evidence of what they're struggling with, and a better understanding of what's getting in the way. There will still be things you don't know. Your first version can help you learn about those.

Consider different ways to help

Take the explanation in your problem sentence and write down different ways you could address it. Give yourself room to think beyond the first product idea you had.

Suppose conversations in our hypothetical designer example suggest that clients struggle to understand what decision is needed. You could try a clearer feedback request. You could provide a page that puts the draft beside the decision the client needs to make. You could help the designer agree on who will approve the work before the project starts.

These approaches ask different things of the designer and the client. A clearer request might fit into the email the designer already sends to the client. A separate page for reviewing drafts might mean asking both people to leave that email exchange and use a new tool. That effort is part of what you're asking them to exchange for the benefit.

Choose an approach that addresses the difficulty you found and is small enough to try with the person you've been talking to. You can test a clearer request by helping write one. You can show how a page would work with a sketch. Some ideas need working software before you can learn much; others give you a useful answer before that.

Describe the value in a sentence

Your notes describe the person and their problem. Now add how your idea might help them:

For [person], who struggles to [outcome] because [obstacle], this helps by [what it does].

For our example, that could become:

For a freelance designer waiting for a clear client decision, this puts the current draft and the decision needed in one place, so the client knows what to respond to.

Put the current draft and the decision needed in one place.

That is a proposal to check with people. It doesn't mean a page will solve the problem. A missing decision-maker or a client with no time to review the work could still leave the designer waiting.

Keep the first version close to this sentence. Features that don't help deliver the promised outcome can wait. You'll have a clearer reason to add them when you see what people actually need.

Take the idea back to someone

Now show the idea to the people you've spoken with. Explain what it does and ask them to walk through how it would fit into their work. You can use the specific project they described earlier to make that discussion concrete.

Ask for a next step that fits what you can offer. With the designer, that might be trying a revised feedback request on a suitable project, then discussing what happened. Agree on what you'd look for: did the client understand the request, and did the reply let the designer move forward?

If you intend to charge for the product, start finding out who would pay and what they're spending on the problem today. The forthcoming Part III will cover pricing, but an assumption about payment belongs on your list now. A friendly reaction to a sketch leaves that question open.

Bring your problem sentence, notes from conversations, and one small idea into Part II. Keep the remaining uncertainties with them. Those notes will help you decide what the first version needs to do and what to learn when someone tries it.

Ready for Part II0 / 4